American Idol Final Two Performances

They are doing 3 songs each tonight. And here are their choices and the judges comments:

Round 1

Katharine McPhee - Black Horse & A Cherry Tree

Randy - She had fun
Paula - She has more and better to come
Simon - Good with a small "g". She needed a bigger song to open with.

Taylor Hicks - For The City

Randy - "Hot One Tonight"
Paula - Loved it
Simon - Round 1 goes to Taylor

Round 2

Katharine - Somewhere Over The Rainbow

Randy - Worked it out
Paula - Made everyone proud
Simon - Her best performance of the competition

Taylor - Levon

Randy - Little pitchy
Paula - Not pitchy at all
Simon - Kat got round 2

Round 3

Katharine - My Destiny

Randy - She looks amazing, sounded good, didn't like the song.
Paula - Brilliant
Simon - She went from brilliant to quite good

Taylor - Do I Make You Proud

Randy - Better song than Katharine's and he made it a Taylor Hicks song
Paula - Agreed completely
Simon - If it was tied after the first two rounds, then Taylor just won.