Tonight On American Idol

Taylor Hicks - Just Once
Randy - It was like weird Karokee
Paula - Wasn't his best performance
Simon - Looked uptight



Chris Daughtry - Have You Ever Really Loved a Woman
Randy - Amazing
Paula - Love you Love you Love you
Simon - Great Performance


Elliott Yamin - Space and Time
Randy - Loved Elliott but hated the arrangement
Paula - He is an American idol(she cried)
Simon - Superb


Katherine McPhee - I Have Nothing
Randy - Good voice but the song was too big for her
Paula - She was pitchy
Simon - Not as good as Whitney Houston


Paris Bennett - The Way We Were
Randy - Liked
Paula - Liked
Simon - Too old fashioned


Kellie Pickler - Unchained Melody
Randy - Pitchy
Paula - Not the greatest
Simon - It was bland and neverending